As the nation prepares itself for General Motors to become Government Motors by virtue of bankruptcy; as families are awaiting the less than hopeful news about Air France flight 447 that has gone missing over the ocean near the west coast of Africa; and as most of us are experiencing difficult times financially due to the economy - some prominent pastors in the Christian blogosphere have voiced concern about a possible trend on whether or not it is appropriate for believers to be "twittering" during worship services. On a scale of 1 to 10 this issue at face value is at best a 2. The only reason I address it here is because some have tried to make what is tertiary, primary.
Surprisingly, one of those pastors is a favorite of mine and maybe yours, Dr. John Piper. I like Piper - especially the books he has penned. He has spent most of his ministry consumed with calling the body of Christ to the supremacy of God in all things; to sound theology in life and practice; to biblical fidelity; to the gospel of sola fide; and to do so with an unmistakable joy and delight in the One Triune God of the Scriptures. It is a holy mission he has been about for which I support him and have benefited greatly. I have featured here recently his videos on President Obama on abortion; the prosperity gospel; and an interview that he did with Tim Keller and D.A. Carson. All excellent and worthy of your time and attention.
That is why it came as a surprise to read his recent words in relation to twittering during worship services.
Here is a portion of his words:
Surprisingly, one of those pastors is a favorite of mine and maybe yours, Dr. John Piper. I like Piper - especially the books he has penned. He has spent most of his ministry consumed with calling the body of Christ to the supremacy of God in all things; to sound theology in life and practice; to biblical fidelity; to the gospel of sola fide; and to do so with an unmistakable joy and delight in the One Triune God of the Scriptures. It is a holy mission he has been about for which I support him and have benefited greatly. I have featured here recently his videos on President Obama on abortion; the prosperity gospel; and an interview that he did with Tim Keller and D.A. Carson. All excellent and worthy of your time and attention.
That is why it came as a surprise to read his recent words in relation to twittering during worship services.
Here is a portion of his words:
Preaching and hearing preaching are worship. Preaching is expository exultation. The preacher is explaining the Bible and applying the Bible and EXULTING over the truth in the Bible. The listener is understanding, and applying, and joining in the exultation. Hearing preaching is heart-felt engagement in the exposition and exultation of the Word of God.The first paragraph I agree with mostly. The last two are seem a bit odd to me.
This is a fragile bond. The fact that an electric cord is easily cut, does not mean that the power flowing through it is small. It produces bright and wonderful effects. So it is with preaching. Great power flows through fragile wires of spiritual focus.
Perfume can break it. A ruffled collar can break it. A cough can break it. A whisper can break it. Clipping fingernails, chewing gum, a memory, a stomach growl, a sunbeam, and a hundred other things can break it. The power that flows through the wire of spiritual attention is strong, but the wire is weak.
Preaching God's Word
Preaching God's Word rightly divided and listening to it with a life desiring to obey its truth is foundational to one's Christian life (cp, 2 Tim. 2:15; 2 Thess. 2:13; 2 Tim. 3:16-4:5; Luke 6:46). Preaching God's Word as a workman unashamed is very important and essential in the worship of our Lord publicly. But it is just as important to present ourselves as living sacrifices daily (Roms. 12:1-2). To eat and drink to the glory of God (1 Cor. 10:31). Confession of sin (Psalm 51; 66:18); unfeigned prayer (Eph. 6:18-21; Luke 18:1); singing a new song in our hearts to the Lord (Psalm 96; Col. 3:16-17; Eph. 5:17-20); or giving cheerfully to the Lord of our finances (2 Cor. 9) is also a valuable part of worship. So while the relationship between preaching and parishioner is valuable, it is only one aspect in biblical worship.
To illustrate, if you are not a preacher, but are doing your vocation or trade with excellence to the Lord, then it is an act of worship to God (Col. 3:17). This was Luther's point paraphrased: "the shoe-maker and the preacher have this in common." IOW, the pastor's work is not more holy than the average Joe doing his job well or the average Jenny investing her life in her home and children. Both are instruments of praise to God and bring exultation to the Lord Jesus Christ. In fact, nowhere does Scripture teach that being filled with the Spirit begins with or finds itself solely in the act of preaching (read Eph. 5:17-20; Gal. 5:20-23). In fact, attitudes and actions such as meditating on God's Word (Psalm 1); craving God's Word (1 Peter 2:2); hiding His Word in your heart (Psalm 119:9-11); obeying God's Word (John 14:15) etc. might have a more important role than the one of preaching God's Word.
Electric Cords Can Be Cut by Whispers and Sunbeams
With that as a premise, where I would respectively and humbly take exception with brother Piper is the notion that the connection between the Word preached and the Word heard is a "fragile bond" that can be "easily cut" because "great power flows through fragile wires of spiritual focus." To suggest that that bond (if there is one) can be easily severed by things such as perfume, whispers, chewing gum, a cough, sunbeams, etc. is silly.
Now for a moment, take John's premise of "fragile wires" being severed by "whispers and sunbeams" and apply that to the preaching ministry of those we see in the Scriptures:
- apply it to Elijah on Mt. Carmel who in front of 450 of Baal's prophets he calls down fire from heaven that consumes the water-drenched sacrifice upon the alter and then brought them down to the brook Kishon and slit their throats (1 Kings 18:20-40).
- apply it to Stephen's last sermon where he is being stoned to death while delivering the gospel (Acts 7).
- try applying that ruffling a collar and stomach noises are sufficient forces to disrupt the Holy Spirit in the ministry of the Word to His people in Sunday worship with the heated inquisition of Paul when preaching at Mars Hill or while he was preaching to the violent crowds at Lystra where the Jews from Antioch and Iconium seized Paul, stoned him, and left him for dead (Acts 17:16ff; 14:8-20).
- bring that fragile axiom into the arena of Peter's great gospel message at Pentecost continuing to his two sermons at Solomon's portico where he was ultimately arrested (Acts 2-4).
- or better yet, apply that to the preaching ministry of John the Baptist or our Lord Himself in their less than quiet, serene settings (Matt. 5-7; Matt. 23; Matt. 3).
The list goes on and on. Respectively, I believe that Piper's assertion that there are delicate cords in which the spiritual forces flow between pastor and pew sounds more like frustrated Monasticism than the biblical preaching of the Lord, the Apostles, the early church fathers, and the reformers of the 15th-18th centuries.
One last example:
Could you imagine the preaching ministry of George Whitefield being defined with fragile electric cords like this? Picture Whitefield fearlessly thundering aloud the gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ while enduring insults both verbal and physical at his meetings. Picture fights breaking out at his meetings; unsavory disgusting things being thrown at him as an act of derision; where he is publicly mocked relentlessly for his severe cross-eyed handicap while he was heralding the gospel. Could you imagine him being concerned about the connection between the Word and the people being prohibited because of "sunbeams and whispers, someone clearing their throat or their stomach making noises", etc.? He would have laughed at the notion that those trite little things were powerful enough to stifle for even a moment the preaching of God's Word to those listening.
Beloved, have the "electric cords" of American Christianity really become that flimsy that pastors today fear they can be lacerated by "whispers and sunbeams?" So we see the ministry of the Holy Spirit in the lives of others while His Word is being proclaimed as so weak that we ourselves have to create an almost perfect atmosphere for Him to operate? For if we do, then I would suggest sleeping in on Sunday. Just stay home, download the best DVD or MP3 you can find on any given text of Scripture and listen to in the peaceful surroundings of your home. What the church in America maybe needs is a bit of sovereign interruption on Sunday morning... Sometimes our carefully cultivated programs and plans need to be shattered to crumble self-reliance, to humble us, and to cause our dependency for all things to be in the Lord alone and not ourselves. This is precisely the place where He will receive the greatest glory and praise (i.e. remember Gideon - Judges 7). If the spiritual forces of the Christian faith proclaimed in a worship service can so easily be cut by a cough or a stomach growl or fingernails being clipped, then what kind of faith are we really proclaiming?
Bring this same logic back to the theme of twittering. It is being suggested that if you "tweet" during a service you are disrupting worship - potentially "cutting the fragile cords." That you are no longer engaged in what the pastor is saying; you are not worshipping; you are too distracted to possibly be communing with God or your fellow believers in reverence to the Lord. Sounds a bit foolish doesn't it?
Under that principle, note taking would cause a similar disturbance along with watching a PowerPoint of the message. Video feeding the pastor's preaching to other campus sites would be as equally disruptive to worship. (You can see where this kind of logic leads).
Twitter Away to the Glory of God
Beloved, if you tweet, then I want to encourage you this week at church to take notes, type on your laptops, use your iPhones and Blackberrys and also tweet away. Use the technology wisely, but use it indeed, to share an encouraging word from His Word being preached. Live-blogging has been condoned by Piper and most evangelical leaders for the past 3 or 4 years. Not one concern was ever voiced about having several web-geeks typing full outlines with textual explanations of what the pastor has just said - in fact it has been praised as being an asset to the ministry not a detriment. So why then when it comes to micro-blogging with twitter has this crossed the line? I don't have the answer either.
May I offer a few helpful suggestions that when you tweet during a worship service (remember you only have 140 characters to use for each entry) you don't waste them:
May I offer a few helpful suggestions that when you tweet during a worship service (remember you only have 140 characters to use for each entry) you don't waste them:
1. May you seek to glorify the Lord by what you say and how you say it (1 Cor. 10:31; Col. 3:17)
2. Write to have your thoughts seasoned with grace, truth and humility (Eph. 4:29)
3. Seek to be redemptive; not just to be right, real, or relevant (Col. 3:8-13)
4. When posting during a worship service, post something that the Lord is teaching you through that service. Encourage someone else that couldn't be in church with a portion of a verse, a thought from the message, or an insight into a verse the pastor has given. Do your normal tweeting and follow up away from church. IOW, sanctify your tweets while in church. This way you honor your pastor and still can use twitter to benefit others (1 Thess. 5:12-14)
5. Don't use your tweets to vent against another, speak wrongly against another, or even sow seeds of discord against another. Take the high ground of Christian charity by not repaying evil for evil. Remember to bless those who curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for those that despitefully use you and persecute you (Matt. 5:44-48)
6. Be respectful of those around you. Just as with anything in a church service don't draw attention to yourself. Consider other people's needs greater than your own. Demonstrate humility and Christian charity. If you tweet, keep them very few in number so you can stay engaged in the service itself (just as with note-taking). (Phil. 2:1-4; Roms. 15:1-10)
7. Lastly, keep your tweets when posting from a worship service focused on what is happening in the service itself. Focus on the passage being preached or the gospel. You never know what follower you have on twitter that needs to be encouraged from the Word of God or in the hope of the gospel. And as you know, they may RT your tweet to hundreds of others on their list as well (Psalm 119:169-176)
Also, here are some real disturbance during a worship service to guard against:
1. Unbiblical, God is my girl-friend songs being offered as praise and worship2. Pastor's who get raptured in their own stories and rhetoric rather than preaching the Word of God3. Alliterations in sermon outlines. Please think hard before using them. Most are not good at it and done poorly can be prohibitive to your preaching and to the listeners to hear ten points forced so all can begin with the letter e4. Mechanical prayers used for transition purposes5. 30 minutes of tremendous Christ-centered worship in song followed by ten minutes of announcements6. Using the famous of society to give credence and validity to the gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ7. Confusing patriotism with biblical Christianity where politicians are given pulpit time to promote moralism but not the gospel8. And lastly, opinion elevated to biblical status because so and so affirms it. Truth by evangelical celebrity preference is a poor foundation to build ones Christian life upon
Twitter Is a Communication Tool - Let's Use it Wisely
Like PowerPoint, live video-feeds. etc. Use it for God and His glory. If the wires between preaching and hearing the Word preached are as weak as Piper might say it is, may I suggest - get better wire.
The initial problem is really not with the one twittering, but with the one behind the pulpit preaching. To the pastors, preach with such power and authority that hearing Christ-centered messages bring us to our faces before a holy God in worship, praise, prayer, reverence, contrition with brokenness and humility. If the Holy Spirit is truly working in that worship service, twittering would not be able break the strong cords of the anointing of the Holy Spirit in worship.
And it just might encourage others not at that service to be encouraged in their walk with the Lord as well.
I appreciate Dr. Piper and His Ministry Greatly
If any of you attend John Piper's church you are blessed. He is a godly man who is one of the finest preachers in the world today. His passion for God and His glory in all things is infectious and contagious. If I were a member of his church I would have one major problem in the worship on Sunday mornings: there is so many good insights that he unfolds in each sermon, it would be very difficult to not want to tweet throughout the entire service so others could be blessed as well :-).
May our worship not be feigned; may we be attentive as God's people to the preaching of His Word; may we be ready and available to minister a word of grace to others as the Lord gives opportunity (even through twitter); may we do so preferring others more than ourselves; and in all we do - do it solely for God and His glory alone through Jesus Christ our Lord in the power of the Holy Spirit!
Let us be both faithful hearers and doers of the Word this week. Amen?
















